THE LUNCH NOTEBOOK

Creamy Cucumber Salad: Mayo, Sour Cream and Greek Yogurt Versions

How to make a creamy cucumber salad three ways, with mayonnaise, sour cream or Greek yogurt dressing, plus salting tips, dill and lemon, and make-ahead advice.

3 min read0 views
— · 0 votes
Contents
  1. Salting cucumbers before dressing
  2. Mayo, sour cream or yogurt
  3. Building it as a make-ahead salad
  4. Questions about creamy cucumber salad
  5. Can I make creamy cucumber salad with Greek yogurt?
  6. What is the difference between mayo and sour cream dressing?
  7. How do I stop creamy cucumber salad from getting watery?
  8. Can I make creamy cucumber salad ahead of time?

A creamy cucumber salad is sliced cucumber coated in a thick, tangy dressing, and the dressing can be built on mayonnaise, sour cream or Greek yogurt. The three versions differ in richness, acidity and how well they hold, so the choice depends on the lunch you are packing. This page covers each dressing, how to keep the salad from turning watery, and how to prepare it ahead.

Salting cucumbers before dressing

Salting the slices first pulls water out of the cucumber so the dressing stays thick. Toss thin slices with a little salt in a colander and let them sit while you mix the dressing. Press them dry in a clean towel before folding in the dressing. Skip this step and the salad turns into soup by lunchtime, especially with a thin yogurt dressing.

Mayo, sour cream or yogurt

Mayonnaise gives the richest, most stable dressing and holds its texture well in a packed lunch. Sour cream brings a lighter tang and a looser body that suits dill and lemon juice. Greek yogurt is the sharpest and thinnest option, so drain it or use a thick strained style. All three accept the same seasoning: salt, pepper, dill and a squeeze of lemon.

Building it as a make-ahead salad

A creamy cucumber salad travels well if you keep the dressing and the cucumber apart until serving. Pack the dressed salad in a sealed container with the dressing in a small jar on the side. Add the dill and lemon at the last moment so the herbs stay bright. Thin slices soften faster than thick ones, so cut thicker rounds for a lunchbox.

Questions about creamy cucumber salad

Can I make creamy cucumber salad with Greek yogurt?

Yes, Greek yogurt makes a sharp, light dressing for cucumber salad. Use a thick strained yogurt, because thin yogurt releases water and makes the dressing runny. Stir in dill, lemon juice, salt and a little oil to soften the tang. Add the dressing just before serving for the firmest texture.

What is the difference between mayo and sour cream dressing?

Mayonnaise makes a denser, richer dressing with a savory edge. Sour cream gives a tangier, looser dressing that tastes lighter on cucumber. Mayonnaise holds its shape better in a packed lunch, while sour cream suits a salad eaten soon after mixing. Some cooks combine the two for body and tang together.

How do I stop creamy cucumber salad from getting watery?

Salt the cucumber slices first and drain the released water before dressing them. Pat the slices dry, then fold in the dressing at the last moment. A thick dressing resists weeping better than a thin one. Keep the dressing separate in a lunchbox and mix it in when you eat.

Can I make creamy cucumber salad ahead of time?

Yes, you can prepare the parts ahead and combine them later. Slice and salt the cucumber, then store it covered in the refrigerator. Mix the dressing in a separate jar and keep it cold. Fold everything together shortly before serving so the cucumber stays crisp.

Read next

Latest articles