Gelatin-Free Marshmallows
How to make gelatin-free marshmallows at home with agar agar or aquafaba, plus what sets the texture and how to whip, set and cut the batch.
Contents
- Agar agar sets the plant-based batch
- Whip the syrup to build air
- Pour, set and cut the slab
- Questions About Gelatin-Free Marshmallows
- Is there a homemade marshmallow recipe without gelatin?
- Are gelatin-free marshmallows the same as vegan marshmallows?
- Does agar agar make marshmallows firm or soft?
- What is aquafaba and how is it used in marshmallows?
Gelatin-free marshmallows are a homemade candy set with a plant-based gelling agent instead of animal gelatin, so the batch stays soft, springy and sliceable. The recipe below uses agar agar, a seaweed extract sold as powder or flakes, to build that bounce. You will see how to whip the syrup, pour it into a tray and cut the set slab into pillows. Aquafaba, the chickpea cooking liquid, offers a second route for anyone avoiding agar.
Agar agar sets the plant-based batch
Agar agar is the gelling agent that gives gelatin-free marshmallows their body, and it comes from red seaweed rather than animal collagen. The powder dissolves in hot liquid and firms as it cools, which traps the air you whip in. Agar sets faster than gelatin, so work quickly once the syrup is ready. Use agar powder rather than flakes where you can, since flakes need a longer soak and give a less even set.
Whip the syrup to build air
Whipping is the step that turns a sweet syrup into a marshmallow, because air bubbles give the candy its spongy bite. Dissolve sugar with water and the agar, then cook the syrup until it thickens slightly. Pour it into a bowl and beat it with an electric mixer until the mixture turns glossy, pale and thick enough to hold a trail. Add vanilla near the end of beating so the flavor stays bright.
Pour, set and cut the slab
A dusted tray is what lets you lift and cut gelatin-free marshmallows once they firm up. Line a square pan with parchment and coat it generously with powdered sugar or a sugar and cornstarch mix. Spread the whipped mixture level, smooth the top and leave the tray undisturbed until the slab feels firm to a light touch. Turn it out onto a sugared board and cut squares with a knife dipped in hot water.
Questions About Gelatin-Free Marshmallows
Is there a homemade marshmallow recipe without gelatin?
Yes, a homemade marshmallow recipe without gelatin replaces it with agar agar or aquafaba. Agar agar powder is dissolved in the hot sugar syrup and sets the candy as it cools. Aquafaba is whipped to a foam and folded or beaten into the syrup for a lighter, airier set. Both routes need a dusted tray and a firm, undisturbed rest before cutting.
Are gelatin-free marshmallows the same as vegan marshmallows?
Vegan marshmallows must be gelatin-free, but gelatin-free marshmallows are not always vegan. Agar agar and aquafaba are plant-based gelling ingredients, so a batch built on either one suits a vegan diet. Refined sugar and some flavorings can be processed with animal products, so check labels if that matters to you. Vegetarian marshmallows may still contain egg white or other animal-derived ingredients.
Does agar agar make marshmallows firm or soft?
Agar agar makes a marshmallow that is firm and clean to cut rather than stretchy like a gelatin candy. The set depends on how much agar you use and how long you cook the syrup, so a heavier hand gives a tougher bite. Agar also sets at a higher temperature, so the mixture starts firming while you spread it. Work fast and keep the tray level for an even slab.
What is aquafaba and how is it used in marshmallows?
Aquafaba is the liquid left from cooking chickpeas, and it whips into a foam that can carry a marshmallow mixture. Beat it until it holds soft peaks, then stream in hot sugar syrup while the mixer runs. The foam traps air and gives a lighter texture than an agar-only batch. Use the liquid from a plain can of chickpeas, without salt or added flavor.