# How to Make Fish Pie Ahead of Time

Learn how to prepare fish pie in advance, cool and store it safely, and reheat it until hot so it is ready for your lunch or dinner.

Making fish pie ahead of time means cooking it in advance and finishing it when you need it. The filling, the sauce and the potato topping can each be prepared before the day you eat. What matters is cooling the pie quickly and keeping it cold until reheating. The sections below explain each step, from assembling the pie to reheating a portion. 

## Preparing the components in advance 

Fish pie can be built in parts, so each component is ready before you bake it. Cook the fish gently in milk or stock, then lift it out and let it cool. Make the white sauce separately and cover its surface with plastic wrap to stop a skin forming. Mash the potatoes with butter and milk, then spread them over the cooled filling. 

## Cooling and storing the assembled pie 

Cool the assembled pie quickly, then place it in the refrigerator. Fast cooling reduces the time the food spends in the temperature range where bacteria grow quickly. Cover the dish with a lid or plastic wrap so the topping does not dry out. Divide the pie into single portions before storing, so each one cools and reheats evenly. 

## Reheating until hot all the way through 

Reheat fish pie until it is piping hot all the way through before serving. A pie reheated from cold needs more time than one that has only been chilled. Heat a portion in the oven or in a microwave, pausing to check the center. Check the middle of the portion with a probe thermometer, and reheat again if it is still lukewarm. 

## Questions about making fish pie ahead 

### Can fish pie be prepared in advance? 

Yes, fish pie can be prepared in advance, as long as it is cooled quickly and kept cold. The filling and sauce can be cooked first with the topping added just before baking. An assembled but unbaked pie needs cold storage until it goes into the oven. Bake it through, check it is hot in the center, and only then serve. 

### How long does fish pie keep in the refrigerator? 

Fish pie keeps in the refrigerator for a period that depends on how quickly it cooled. A pie that cooled quickly and stayed chilled can be eaten later, unlike one left out. Discard any pie that smells or tastes off before you eat it. Do not leave the pie at room temperature while you pack or serve it. 

### How should fish pie be reheated? 

Fish pie should be reheated in an oven or microwave until it is hot all the way through. An oven heats the dish evenly, while a microwave can leave cold spots near the center. A splash of milk can loosen thickened sauce before the pie goes back in the oven. Cover the dish loosely with foil so the top does not burn while the middle heats through. 

### Does fish pie need to be cooked again after storing? 

Yes, fish pie stored after baking should be reheated thoroughly before eating. Reheating brings the whole dish back to a temperature that is safe to eat. Fish is delicate, so it can overcook on a second heating, which makes the flesh dry. Heat portions gently and avoid reheating the same portion more than once.
