THE LUNCH NOTEBOOK

How to Press Homemade Tortillas With a Tortilla Press

Learn how to press homemade corn and flour tortillas with a tortilla press, covering dough, lining the press, pressing, cooking and storing each batch.

8 min read6 viewsHow to Press Homemade Tortillas With a Tortilla Press
— · 0 votes
Contents
  1. What a tortilla press does
  2. Choosing dough for corn or flour tortillas
  3. Portioning the dough into balls
  4. Lining the press and pressing
  5. Cooking pressed tortillas in a pan
  6. Matching the pan to each dough
  7. Storing and reheating homemade tortillas
  8. Questions about pressing homemade tortillas
  9. Can you press flour tortilla dough in a tortilla press?
  10. Do you need parchment paper to press tortillas?
  11. Why does my homemade tortilla crack at the edges?
  12. Can I make tortillas without a tortilla press?
  13. How do you keep pressed tortillas soft after cooking?

You can make homemade tortillas with a tortilla press by flattening dough balls between two sheets. The press gives each tortilla an even thickness before it cooks. Corn tortillas use masa harina, while flour tortillas use wheat flour.

  • Mix masa harina or flour with water until the dough feels soft and holds together.
  • Press each dough ball between two sheets of plastic or parchment paper.
  • Cook each pressed tortilla on a hot dry pan until it puffs and browns in spots.
  • Keep unused dough covered so it does not dry out at the edges.
  • Wrap cooked tortillas in a clean towel so they stay soft while cooling.

What a tortilla press does

A tortilla press is a hinged or lever tool that flattens a ball of dough into a round. Two flat plates press the dough evenly from the top and bottom. Because the pressure stays even, the tortillas come out at a similar thickness. Pressing by hand with a rolling pin takes more practice to get the same result.

A press suits anyone who wants round tortillas without rolling each piece by hand. The tool does one job, so it needs a few other items to make a full batch. Those items include a bowl, a pan, a cloth, and two sheets for lining the press. Plan the work so the dough stays covered while you press each piece.

Press models differ in size, material, and the way the handle works. Check that the plates are wide enough for the size of tortilla you want. A press with a larger plate fits a wider tortilla but takes up more counter space. Cast iron presses are heavy, which helps, but they need care to stay dry.

Choosing dough for corn or flour tortillas

Corn tortillas are made from masa harina, a flour made from treated corn. Mix masa harina with warm water until the dough feels like soft clay. Let the dough rest, then check the texture before you shape any balls. Corn dough cracks at the edges when it is too dry and tears when too wet.

Flour tortilla dough uses wheat flour, fat, salt, and warm water. The fat keeps the tortillas soft and makes the dough easier to press. Let flour dough rest under a cloth so the gluten, its stretchy protein, relaxes. Flour dough that is too stiff springs back and resists the press.

Each dough gives a different texture, so match the dough to the tortilla you plan. Compare the doughs by their main ingredient and what each one does in the pan. Corn dough gives a sturdy, slightly grainy tortilla with a toasted corn flavor. Flour dough gives a soft, pliable tortilla that folds without cracking.

  • Masa harina dough: sturdy and grainy, with a toasted corn flavor
  • Wheat flour dough: soft and pliable, and it folds without cracking
  • Flour dough with extra fat: tender, but it dries out if left uncovered

Portioning the dough into balls

Divide the rested dough into equal pieces before you press any tortilla. Roll each piece between your palms to form a smooth, round ball. Pieces of the same size press into tortillas that cook at the same rate. Uneven balls give thin and thick spots that cook unevenly in the pan.

Keep the balls under a damp cloth while you work through the rest. Dry air dries the outside of a dough ball and cracks it at the edge. Use a little flour on your hands if the dough sticks, but keep it light. Too much flour makes the tortilla dry and stops the edges from sealing.

Some cooks flatten each ball with a palm before it goes into the press. A light pre-flatten helps a thick ball close fully in the press. Hold the ball at its center so it sits flat on the bottom plate. A ball that sits off center pushes out a lopsided tortilla.

Lining the press and pressing

Line the bottom plate with a sheet of parchment paper or plastic. A sheet keeps the dough from sticking to the metal and the press. Set the dough ball on the sheet, then cover it with a second sheet. Plastic from a bag works, though thick plastic gives a cleaner surface.

Close the press gently until the top plate meets the dough. Press with steady pressure, then open the press and check the thickness. Pressing too hard can tear the dough or squeeze out the sides of the sheet. Press again only if the tortilla is still thick, not to thin it further.

Peel the top sheet away slowly so the tortilla does not stick to it. Lift the tortilla off the bottom sheet with your fingertips or a thin spatula. Move the pressed tortilla to a plate covered with a cloth until you cook it. Pressed tortillas tear more easily when they are left to sit uncovered.

Cooking pressed tortillas in a pan

Cook a pressed tortilla on a hot, dry pan or griddle without oil. Heat the pan until a drop of water sizzles and skips across the surface. Lay the tortilla on the pan and leave it alone until the edges lift. Turn it once, then cook the second side until light brown spots appear.

Flip the tortilla with tongs so your fingers stay clear of the heat. Hot pans and steam can burn skin, so keep a towel within reach. Press the edges gently with the tongs if a tortilla puffs unevenly. A puffed tortilla means the dough had enough moisture to steam inside.

A tortilla that stays pale and stiff may need more heat under the pan. Adjust the heat between batches, since a cold tortilla cools the pan. Stack cooked tortillas only after they stop steaming, so they do not sweat. Cooking is complete when the tortilla feels flexible and holds its shape.

Matching the pan to each dough

Corn dough and flour dough both cook on a hot dry pan, but they behave differently. Corn tortillas need the heat to set the surface before they bend. Flour tortillas bubble more often and show darker spots on the thin areas. Watch the color rather than the clock, since each dough browns at its own rate.

The table below sets out how each dough behaves in the pan. Use it as a guide and adjust the heat to suit your own pan. Each row lists a dough, the pan heat it suits, and the texture it gives. Read the texture first when you judge whether a tortilla is done.

Masa harina dough needs steady heat at first, then a little less. Wheat flour dough tolerates a slightly cooler pan and stays pliable longer. Pressing the tortilla thin matters more than the exact pan setting. Cook a test tortilla from each dough before you press a full batch.

DoughPan heatTexture to expect
Masa harinaSteady and hotSturdy and grainy
Wheat flourHot but gentlerSoft and pliable
Flour with fatMedium, watch the edgesTender, dries if uncovered

Storing and reheating homemade tortillas

Store cooled homemade tortillas in a sealed bag or container to keep them moist. Let them cool fully first, since trapped steam makes them soggy. Add a folded towel inside the bag to absorb extra moisture. Check the bag for mold or an off smell before you eat any tortilla.

Reheat a stored tortilla on a dry pan for a short time to soften it. Wrap it in a damp towel first if you want it extra soft. Warm it in a microwave between damp paper towels as a quicker option. Stay near the stove or microwave while heating, so nothing overheats.

Raw dough balls can be wrapped tightly so they stay workable for the next press. Keep any extra dough in a sealed container in the refrigerator. Let refrigerated dough return to room temperature before you press it. Cold dough cracks more and may need a little water worked back in.

Questions about pressing homemade tortillas

Can you press flour tortilla dough in a tortilla press?

Yes, you can press flour tortilla dough in a tortilla press. Wheat flour dough is soft and pliable, so it presses well between two sheets. Let the dough rest under a cloth first, so it relaxes and does not spring back. Press it gently and cook the tortilla on a hot pan.

Do you need parchment paper to press tortillas?

No, parchment paper is not required, since plastic sheets also work for pressing. Parchment or plastic keeps the dough from sticking to the metal plates. Thick plastic gives a cleaner surface, and a clean sheet is easy to replace. Place one sheet on the bottom plate and a second sheet over the dough ball.

Why does my homemade tortilla crack at the edges?

Cracked edges mean the dough is too dry or the ball was not covered while you worked. Dough that is too stiff springs back and splits when you press it. Add water a few drops at a time and knead until it feels soft. Cover the balls with a damp cloth so they do not dry at the edges.

Can I make tortillas without a tortilla press?

Yes, you can flatten dough balls by hand or with a rolling pin. Place each ball between two sheets and press with a flat pan or a heavy plate. Even thickness takes more practice when you flatten by hand. The tortillas still cook on a hot pan the same way.

How do you keep pressed tortillas soft after cooking?

Wrap cooked tortillas in a clean towel while they cool. Cool them fully before sealing, because trapped steam makes them limp. Reheat them briefly on a dry pan or in a damp towel before serving. Seal them in a bag or container so they keep their moisture.

Read next

Latest articles