Pastry Cream Thickened Without Cornstarch or With Flour
Learn how to thicken pastry cream with flour instead of cornstarch, how the cooking changes, and how to avoid a raw flour taste in the custard.
Contents
- What flour does in pastry cream
- Ingredients for a flour-thickened custard
- Steps for cooking flour into the custard
- Flour compared with cornstarch
- Avoiding a raw flour taste
- Cooling and storing the finished cream
- Using pastry cream in tarts and filled pastries
- Questions about flour-thickened pastry cream
- Can you make pastry cream with flour instead of cornstarch?
- How do you keep flour pastry cream from tasting raw?
- Does cornstarch give a smoother pastry cream than flour?
- How much flour replaces cornstarch in pastry cream?
- Can a flour pastry cream be frozen?
Pastry cream can be thickened with all-purpose flour instead of cornstarch, using egg yolks, milk, sugar and vanilla. Flour needs to be brought to a boil and held there, which removes its raw taste. The result is a smooth, thick custard that suits tarts and filled pastries.
- Use all-purpose flour as the thickener when cornstarch is not available or not wanted.
- Flour needs a larger weight than cornstarch to reach the same firmness.
- Whisk the flour into the yolks first to keep lumps out of the custard.
- Bring the cream to a full boil while whisking to cook out the raw taste.
- Chill it covered, and do not freeze a flour-thickened cream.
What flour does in pastry cream
All-purpose flour thickens pastry cream by swelling its starch in hot milk and egg mixture. The starch has to reach a boil before the custard sets to a smooth, spoonable texture. Egg yolks add richness and help the cream set as it cooks. Flour gives a softer, less glossy finish than cornstarch does in the same recipe.
Flour holds protein as well as starch, which is why it behaves differently from cornstarch. Protein does not thicken like starch does, so more flour is needed for the same firmness. Measuring the flour by weight, not by volume, keeps the texture predictable from batch to batch. Sifting the flour first also stops small lumps from forming in the hot liquid.
Flour-thickened pastry cream suits tarts and filled pastries that are cut or piped. Its softer set can hold a shape when it is piped, though it may feel less silky. Cornstarch gives a glossier, silkier result that some cooks prefer for thin fillings. Chocolate or coffee flavors can hide some of the difference in texture.
Ingredients for a flour-thickened custard
A flour-thickened pastry cream needs milk, egg yolks, sugar, flour and a flavoring such as vanilla. Whole milk gives a richer cream, while lower-fat milk makes a lighter one. Use the vanilla bean split and scraped, or use extract, depending on what you have. Egg yolks should be whisked smooth with the sugar and a little of the warm milk first.
Mix the flour into the yolk and sugar mixture before adding the hot milk. Adding the flour to the yolks first keeps lumps from forming in the pan. Whisk until no dry pockets of flour remain, because they are hard to break up once heated. Some recipes sieve the finished custard as well, to catch any stray lumps.
Keep the milk warm rather than boiling when you add it to the eggs. Adding hot milk slowly stops the yolks from scrambling as they warm. A thermometer helps you track the heat, though a spoon can also show when the mixture coats it. Keep a steady hand on the whisk, because the base can thicken unevenly if it sits still.
Steps for cooking flour into the custard
Cooking flour into pastry cream takes steady heat and constant whisking from start to finish. Set the pan over medium heat and keep the base moving across the bottom and sides. Watch for the first bubbles at the edges, which signal that the mixture is getting hot enough. Keep the heat on until the cream thickens noticeably and the whisk leaves lines in it.
Once it thickens, the flour needs a full boil to cook out its raw taste. Keep whisking through the boil and for a short while after it begins to bubble. Remove the pan from the heat once the cream is smooth and holds its shape. Stir in the vanilla while the cream is still hot, then pass it through a sieve.
Pour the cream into a clean dish and press plastic wrap directly onto its surface. Let it cool at room temperature until it is no longer steaming, then chill it. Whisk the chilled cream briefly before piping or spreading it into a shell. Work carefully with a boiling liquid, since steam and splashes can cause serious burns.
- Whisk the flour into the yolk and sugar mixture first.
- Warm the milk and add it to the yolks slowly while whisking.
- Cook over medium heat, whisking the base across the bottom and sides.
- Bring the cream to a full boil and keep whisking through it.
- Cool the cream covered with plastic wrap pressed on its surface.
Flour compared with cornstarch
Flour and cornstarch both thicken pastry cream, but they differ in amount and finish. Cornstarch is nearly pure starch, so it thickens at a lower weight. Flour needs a larger weight than cornstarch for the same firmness. The table below compares the two thickeners across the main points of a custard.
Cornstarch gives a clear, glossy finish once the cream has boiled and cooled. Flour leaves a softer, slightly opaque cream that can taste floury if undercooked. Both thickeners need a boil to set, so skipping that step leaves the cream thin. Each thickener suits a different finish, so the choice depends on the dessert.
Cornstarch fits recipes where a clear, silky texture is the goal. Flour fits recipes where a softer, sturdier custard is wanted, or when cornstarch is missing. Neither option is wrong, but the dish should match the texture you want. Check the recipe for the amount listed and avoid swapping by volume alone.
| Point | All-purpose flour | Cornstarch |
|---|---|---|
| Amount needed | More by weight | Less by weight |
| Finish | Softer, slightly opaque | Clear and glossy |
| Raw taste risk | Present if undercooked | Little when fully cooked |
| Texture when chilled | Sturdier, holds a shape | Silkier, spreads smoothly |
Avoiding a raw flour taste
A raw flour taste comes from starch that has not been cooked through in the pan. Keep the cream at a full boil while whisking, so the starch swells completely. Pull the pan from the heat only after the cream has bubbled and thickened fully. Tasting a small spoonful after cooling shows whether the flour flavor is gone.
A slight floury note can be softened with more vanilla or a pinch of salt. Covering the cream and letting it sit does not remove a raw taste. Cooking the flour properly in the pan is the only reliable fix. Adding more flour to fix a taste makes the cream heavier, not cleaner.
Tiny lumps are another sign of undercooked flour or flour added too quickly. Pressing the cream through a sieve removes lumps but not an off taste. Use a heatproof spatula or whisk that reaches the corners of the pan. Scraping the corners stops small bits of flour from scorching and spoiling the batch.
Cooling and storing the finished cream
Cover pastry cream closely with plastic wrap as soon as it stops steaming. Pressing the wrap onto the surface keeps a skin from forming. Refrigerate the cream once it has cooled, since warm dairy spoils quickly. Keep it cold until you assemble the dessert, and do not leave it on the counter.
A chilled flour custard firms more than a fresh one, so it may need a gentle whisk. Loosen it with a spoonful of cold milk if it feels stiff before piping. Do not reheat a cream that has sat out, since it may be unsafe to eat. When in doubt, throw the cream away rather than risk a stomach upset.
Store the cream in a clean, covered container that seals well. Label the container with the date you made it so you can track its age. Freezing pastry cream is not recommended, because the texture can turn grainy when thawed. Cream made on the day of use gives the cleanest flavor and texture.
Using pastry cream in tarts and filled pastries
Pastry cream made with flour fills tart shells, cream puffs and layered cakes. Spoon the cooled cream into a baked shell and level the top with a flat spatula. Add fresh fruit just before serving, since juice can soften the crust over time. Pack the tart in a cooler bag if the filling must stay chilled.
Cream puffs filled with flour-thickened cream hold their shape well when piped. Fill them just before serving so the pastry stays crisp and dry. A thin layer of cream under fruit or chocolate suits many of these pastries. Spread the cream evenly so that every bite has the same texture.
Flavorings like lemon zest or espresso can be stirred into the cooled cream. Add a flavoring after cooking so that the boil does not dull its taste. Test a spoonful before filling the whole batch, since the flavor may read stronger when chilled. Adjust sugar and flavoring on the cooled cream, not on the hot base.
Questions about flour-thickened pastry cream
Can you make pastry cream with flour instead of cornstarch?
Yes, all-purpose flour can thicken pastry cream in place of cornstarch. Use more flour by weight than you would use cornstarch. Cook the mixture to a full boil while whisking, then keep it cooking briefly. The finished cream will be softer and less glossy, with a slightly opaque look.
How do you keep flour pastry cream from tasting raw?
Cook the flour fully at a full boil while whisking, which removes the raw taste. Keep the heat on until the cream has bubbled and thickened all the way through. A slight floury note can be softened with more vanilla, but cooking is the only reliable fix.
Does cornstarch give a smoother pastry cream than flour?
Cornstarch gives a clearer and silkier pastry cream than flour does. Flour makes a softer, slightly opaque custard that holds a shape when piped. Both thickeners work, and the dessert decides which texture fits.
How much flour replaces cornstarch in pastry cream?
No fixed amount applies to every recipe, so weigh the flour rather than guess by volume. Flour needs a larger weight than cornstarch for the same firmness. Adjust the flour by weight from your original recipe's cornstarch amount, testing as you go.
Can a flour pastry cream be frozen?
Freezing is not recommended for flour-thickened pastry cream, because its texture can turn grainy when thawed. Thawing and whisking may not restore the smooth set of a fresh batch. Keep the cream chilled in a covered container and use it on the day it is made.